What to look for when buying a used golf putter 

Buying a used putter can be a smart way to upgrade your equipment without paying full retail prices. Compared to brand new models, used putters typically come at a significantly lower cost, often 30-60% cheaper depending on condition, age and brand. However, unlike new clubs, used putters may show signs of wear and tear such as face marks, shaft rust, grip deterioration or minor cosmetic damage. While cosmetic marks won’t affect performance, structural issues can. That’s why we carefully inspect every club that comes through our doors here at next2newgolf.

Knowing what type of putter would suit your game best is also extremely important. From traditional style blades to larger mallets and the newest zero-torque designs, each style is best suited to different strokes and player preferences. A dedicated guide helps you understand what truly impacts performance, including condition, length and putter type, so that you can buy with confidence. 

Main Takeaways

• Face wear, shaft condition and grip condition are all key elements to check when looking for a used putter. 

• Used putters typically cost 30-60% less than buying new (e.g. £40-£200 used to £150-£400+ new)

• Know what type of putter suits your stroke before you start shopping. 

What to consider when buying a used golf putter 

1. Condition

Condition is an important factor to consider when buying a used putter, or any used club. Cosmetic wear is normal and expected, and putters often last longer than other clubs, as they aren’t used at the same speeds or as forcefully as the other clubs in your bag. 

The condition of the face, shaft and grip must all be assessed. For the face, keep an eye out for worn inserts or surface marks as this may affect roll and distance control. Check the shaft for any rust or pitting, now this may not affect the performance but can often be an indicator as to how the club has been cared for. Finally, assess the grip. A worn or slick grip may reduce control and consistency, though they are fairly inexpensive to replace. 

All of our used putters we sell here at next2newgolf have clear, high quality photos and detailed descriptions, making it easy to see the condition of each part of the club before purchasing.

Understanding condition grading and the terms used in the grading process helps set realistic expectations. Our grading levels consist of: brand new, as new, excellent, good, fair and poor. We assign one of these grades to each part of the club, so buyers can see exactly where any wear might exist. Each grade reflects both the cosmetic appearance and overall usability of the club, allowing buyers to make more informed decisions on what used putter to buy. 

2. Length & Spec 

Putter length plays a major role in posture, eye position and stroke consistency. Choosing the right length putter ensures that your stance is comfortable, your eyes are properly aligned over the ball, and your stroke remains repeatable. Some used putters may have been custom fit for their previous owner, so it’s important to know what length putter you’re getting before you buy.

If a putter is too long, your eyes may sit too far inside the ball line, making it harder to maintain proper alignment. Too short, and you may hunch over, creating tension in your back and shoulders that can affect stroke smoothness. Standard putter lengths vary from 33 to 35 inches, but the ideal length depends on your height, posture and putting style. 

When buying used, it's important to measure or confirm the exact length rather than relying on assumptions. This is why we list the length of a putter in the title of every used putter on our website. Because even small differences can impact comfort and consistency on the greens. Some golfers may prefer slightly longer or shorter putters depending on their stance or whether they use an upright or flat posture. 

By paying attention to the length, you can ensure a natural, comfortable setup that supports a smooth stroke and accurate roll, making it easier to translate your practice into performance on the course and result in holing more putts. 

3. Putter type

Choosing the right putter type is just as important, if not more than length and condition. Not all putters suit every stroke, and selecting one that matches your natural motion can make a noticeable difference in consistency and confidence on the greens. 

There are many different types of putters but we generally separate them into 3 different categories: blades, mallets and zero-torque putters. Blades are generally smaller, more traditional in shape and suited for golfers with a slight arc in their stroke, often providing precise feel in distance control. Mallet putters are larger, often more forgiving and designed for golfers with a straight-back and straight-through stroke, usually including better alignment and more weight behind the ball. Zero torque putters on the other hand are the latest step in technological advancement within the golf world. These putters are designed to maintain a straight face through impact, even when a poor stroke was put on the ball, designed to be super forgiving and coming in blade and mallet designs they’ve taken the professional and amateur worlds by storm. 

When buying a used putter, it’s important to match the head style to your stroke type. A brand new £400 putter that doesn’t suit your stroke will more than likely be worse for you than a used £40 putter that does suit your stroke. Understanding the differences between these different putter types ensures your purchase supports your game rather than working against it. 

4. Reputable brand

The brand of a putter can significantly influence quality, feel and long term performance. Established manufacturers invest in research, precision milling and advanced face technologies. Often resulting in a more consistent roll, improved distance control and better overall feel. 

Buying a used putter allows golfers to access premium brands at a fraction of the brand new price, making it possible to own a higher quality product without breaking the bank. Well known brands tend to retain their value better, which can also be an important consideration if you plan to resell or upgrade in the future. 

Popular brands often offer signature design features such as precision milled faces, custom weighting or specialised inserts all aimed at enhancing stroke consistency, feel and confidence on the greens. While performance and personal fit should always come first, choosing a reputable brand provides added reassurance in terms of craftsmanship, durability and long term reliability. 

When selecting a used putter, familiarising yourself with respected brands and their signature models helps you identify clubs that are likely to deliver predictable performance and maintain value over time. This knowledge allows you to make a smart, informed purchase that balances cost, quality and enjoyment. If you’re unsure on what a reputable brand might consist of, check out our blog post on reliable golf brands. But for putters specifically you can’t really go wrong with a PING, Taylormade, Odyssey or Scotty Cameron putter. 

5. Weight & Feel

The weight of a putter head plays a major role in distance control, stroke tempo and overall consistency. Modern putters often feature adjustable weight systems on the bottom of the head so that one club can be adjusted to suit multiple different strokes and needs. Heavier putters are generally suited to slower smoother strokes and lighter putters are often used to promote a faster stroke. Understanding how weight affects your putting can make a noticeable difference in comfort and performance. 

Feel is highly personal and refers to how soft or firm the ball feels off the face at impact, it’s influenced by face inserts, milling patterns and the materials used. Softer feeling faces typically allow you to feel like you’re putting a firmer, more confident stroke on the ball. However, some golfers prefer a more solid contact so it feels less like a hit and more a controlled stroke. This is all down to personal preference but understanding which you prefer is key to building more confidence and consistency on the greens. 

When evaluating a used putter, take note of both the weight and feel off the face. Even if a putter looks good and matches your length, a weight that feels off can ruin your tempo or a face that feels too firm/soft can impact distance control and your ability to make repeatable strokes on the greens. 

6. Aesthetics

While performance should always come first, there’s a lot to be said for the look and style of a putter as it can have a meaningful impact on confidence and comfort at address. A putter that looks nice and appealing to your eye is going to make you feel more confident, improve focus and commitment to each stroke. Conversely, a club that might theoretically be perfect for your stroke and feel, but just doesn’t appeal to your eye will diminish your confidence and introduce more inconsistent strokes into your game. 

Aesthetics includes aspects such as head shape, finish, colour and alignment aids. Blade putters tend to offer a more traditional look, while mallets offer more modern, forgiving shapes with larger alignment lines. Finishes can range from classic polished chrome or satin steel to matte or darker coatings designed to reduce glare on sunny days. Even subtle details like engraving milling or painted lines on the face can affect both visual appeal and confidence over the ball. Alignment features play a large role in the aesthetics of a putter, as they can make lining up putts easier and more intuitive. You can find options from a 2-ball look, to bold white lines or even a simplistic dot for a minimalist approach. The type of alignment aid you prefer can help you commit more fully to each stroke. 

When buying a putter no matter if it’s new or used, always consider what factors you might want to prioritise from the style, finish and alignment features. 

7. Resale value

One of the biggest advantages to buying a used putter is that the club has already experienced its largest depreciation. This means that, with proper care, you can often resell the putter later on with minimal loss, making it a low risk investment in your equipment. Understanding resale value allows you to make smarter buying decisions and plan for future upgrades. 

Not all putters hold value equally. Popular brands and well-known models tend to retain value better due to demand, reputation and perceived quality. Limited edition releases, premium milled designs or zero torque designs also maintain stronger resale value, while less recognisable models or basic designs may see faster depreciation. Knowing which types of putters historically retain value can help you make a more informed purchase. 

The condition of the putter also plays a major role in resale value. Well maintained clubs with minimal cosmetic wear and clean grips will always command higher resale prices. Using clear photos, accurate descriptions and condition grading like how we do here at next2newgolf, ensures buyers understand the state of the club and can price it fairly when reselling. 

Considering resale value is particularly important if you regularly update your equipment. Buying smart on the used market not only gives you access to premium brands and models at a lower cost but also makes future upgrades more affordable. Ultimately, a well chosen used putter can provide excellent performance today while maintaining value for tomorrow, turning your purchase into a practical, low risk investment. 

The types of putters to be aware of

When buying a used putter, understanding the type of club you’re considering is essential. Different designs suit different strokes, offer varying levels of forgiveness and can affect pricing on the second hand market. 

Blade putters are the more traditional style, with a slim, straight profile and minimal offset. They are generally preferred by golfers with a slight arc in their putting stroke who value precision. They very often feature milled faces built to provide feel and consistency. On the used market, high quality blade putters from reputable brands retain their value well due to craftsmanship, consistent performance and collector appeal, for example Scotty Cameron blade putters. While generally simpler in design than mallets or zero torque putters, premium blades made with quality materials or advanced face milling can command higher prices, even second hand. 

Mallet putters are generally larger and heavier, designed for stability and forgiveness, particularly on off centre strikes. They often feature perimeter weighting and prominent alignment aids like bold lines or the infamous 2-ball alignment from odyssey that’s been a fan favourite for decades. In the second hand market, mallets can be priced higher than blades because their design typically incorporates more technology to improve stroke consistency and alignment. Popular brands with advanced inserts, multi material heads or innovative weighting systems can drive resale value further, a good example of this is the Taylormade Spider series which have been best sellers for the best part of the last decade. For golfers seeking confidence and forgiveness, investing in a high quality used mallet is often worth the extra cost. 

Zero-torque putters are engineered to minimise face twist through the stroke and through impact, helping maintain stable strokes and consistent roll. Initially introduced and patented by L.A.B, but quickly followed by Taylormade, Odyssey and PING creating their own versions of zero torque putters, the new trend has seemingly taken the golfing world by storm. They often combine elements of mallets and blades, using precise weighting and face technology to reduce rotation. Because of their advanced engineering, zero torque putters from premium brands tend to hold higher resale value, even used. Buyers should expect to pay significantly more for these putters due to the advanced technologies going into building these putters. Perfect for golfers looking for more help on the greens, zero torque putters can be a worthwhile investment. 

As I’ve already mentioned above, even when buying new or used, you should always consider what type of putter would be best suited to your game in terms of the type and in terms of other factors such as alignment and weight. Brand and technology will often drive the price, popular brands and putters with advanced technologies will always retain high value, while lesser known models may be more affordable but less sought after. 

By understanding the differences between blades, mallets and zero torque putters, you can make a more informed decision that balances performance, feel and value on the second hand market. 

Making the right putter choice for you 

Choosing the right used putter starts with understanding what matters most to you as a golfer. Before focusing on brand or price, ask yourself a few key questions: what type of stroke do I have? Do I struggle more with alignment or distance control? Do I prefer a softer or firmer feel off the face? 

If you have a natural arc in your stroke, a blade will suit you better. If you want more forgiveness and alignment support, a mallet will be the smarter option. If consistency and face stability are your biggest priorities, a zero torque design will benefit you most. Matching the putter type to your stroke is the first step and most important decisions you can make with your golf bag. 

Next consider the feel and weight of your ideal putter. Would you rather a soft or firm feel from the club? Heavier heads can promote a smoother tempo, while lighter models may feel more responsive. If you’re buying used, carefully reviewing the condition of the face, shaft and grip is equally an important step of the process. 

Budget and resale value will also factor into the decision, premium brands and newer technologies may cost more, but they should ultimately give you a higher level of performance and they’ll also hold more value later on when you may look to upgrade in the future. 

Ultimately the right putter is one that inspires confidence at address, suits your stroke, feels comfortable in your hands and fits your budget.

Conclusion  

Buying a used putter is about more than just price, it’s understanding fit, feel, condition and long term value. By considering all the conditions mentioned above, you can make a confident and informed decision. At Next2NewGolf, our detailed grading system, clear photography and specialist knowledge help ensure you know exactly what you’re buying. Whether you’re upgrading your current model or wanting to try something new, buying used can be a smart cost effective way to improve your game. Explore our related guides for more expert insights into choosing the right equipment for your game.